Thursday, December 10, 2015

American School System

The school system of America is no doubt flawed. In Leon Botstein's article Let Teenagers Try Adulthood he proposes the fact that children are reaching adolescence at an earlier age. The culture of our society has become increasingly sexualized and children are reaching physical maturity at an earlier age. These two facts are what Botstein uses to support his argument that the school system should start at an earlier age (4) and end earlier as well (16).
While I completely agree with Botstein that the school system needs some major renovations I think his support for his argument is weak. There are millions of reasons that the school system is messed up but his argument does not make sense to me. He says that the school system needs to end when students are 16 because that is when they are ready to "enter the real world" since they are physically and sexually mature. So by this argument reaching puberty and losing your virginity make you an adult and no longer need school. A 16 year old may or may not know what they want to do with their lives. Even if they have an idea of what they'd like to do they do not have enough knowledge and experience to be able to work in that career. Whether or not you are a virgin has nothing to do with it.
The school system does need to be changed. I agree with Botstein that middle school should be eliminated. I think that up until our current 8th grade students should learn a basis of many different subjects as they do now. Then high school should be structured more like an undergraduate school. There some core classes will be required but students will also have an ability to choose classes. This was students who know what they want to do can focus there classes into a specific field while students who are unsure can study many different things until they find something they enjoy. The school system also needs to be unified so that it is ensured you can get the same education everywhere. Botstein's idea of changing the school system is great but I do not agree with his reasoning for it. Whatever the reason is we can all agree that the school system needs some modifications.

No comments:

Post a Comment